Tell us what you think.
Note: your comment is not published straight away. I check and approve all comments, otherwise the spammers get a free rein. I usually check comments within 24 hours.

* 14 comments… read them below and tell us what you think.

Pat Rosier 15 July 2009 at 10:45:53

Another great tip. I’m writing comments on files all over the place! Especially useful for showing what version of a poem or short story I have entered in a competition – much better – more specific – than colour coding the file. Not as much fun as my new ipod touch, but v v useful. Thank you, Miraz

Reply

Maureen Small 22 July 2009 at 09:05:23

Any idea why every so often I get one file that won’t let me add a comment? I just can’t get a cursor to appear in the Spotlight comment box. All the files I’m doing are video files of some kind, but it doesn’t seem to be related to the extension – works on some MPEG or avi files, but not on others.

Reply

Miraz Jordan 22 July 2009 at 14:24:54

Maureen: obviously the name and file size would be different, but is anything else different between files where you can and cannot add comments?

I wonder if some files are on a different drive, or in a directory where you don’t have permissions to edit them?

Or are the problem files Locked? You would need to uncheck the ‘Locked’ checkbox, add the comment and then lock them again.

Reply

Maureen Small 23 July 2009 at 03:32:13

I checked the locked box right away, and it is not checked. All of the files are on the same drive, but I do wonder if when they were created, someone set permissions that I’m unaware of. It’s not a huge deal because I’ve so far only come across 2 out of about 100, but it is perplexing and a bit annoying!

Reply

Miraz Jordan 23 July 2009 at 13:09:23

Maureen: try this. Identify one file where comments do work, and another they don’t. Then Get Info on both and compare. Look at Sharing and Permissions at the botto of the Get Info window. You may need to expand the disclosure triangle.

If you see differences try to set the uncooperative file to be the same as the one that works. To make changes you may need to click the padlock and enter the password for your computer.

Reply

Maureen Small 24 July 2009 at 05:53:47

Once again, you came to the rescue! Yes, that was the problem – those two were marked “read only” for me, which I was able to change. Thanks!

Reply

Miraz Jordan 24 July 2009 at 07:22:41

H Maureen,

it’s so satisfying to achieve a ‘fix’ like this. Glad we could get it sorted. :-)

Reply

James 30 July 2009 at 05:28:39

Is there a way to change comments for multiple files at the same time?

Reply

Danny 23 November 2009 at 05:56:06

If you use Pathfinder (www.cocoatech.com) the ‘Multiple Items Info’ window DOES make the file comments field available. (See Miraz’s comment below.) …just one way Pathfinder is superuseful.

Reply

Miraz Jordan 23 November 2009 at 07:03:25

Thanks Danny. I’m a fan of Pathfinder myself. :-)

Reply

Graphic Designer Christchurch 15 August 2009 at 16:29:02

Thanks for the tip. I’ve been struggling with this for a while.

Reply

Miraz Jordan 15 August 2009 at 16:49:43

James: if you select multiple items and choose Command Control i then a ‘Multiple Items Info’ window appears where you can change various properties such as which application opens those files, and sharing permissions.

Unfortunately it doesn’t make the File Comments area available.

An Applescript may do the job. I tried the script mentioned on this page on 4 files and it added the comment I supplied to all 4 files:

http://www.mactipper.com/2009/03/welcome2mac-spotlight-comments-and.html

If it works for you, please let us know.

Reply

Lisa 24 January 2010 at 16:04:26

It’s not just “read only” that is the problem I’ve discovered. In some cases you have to click the little wheel at the bottom of the Get Info screen and select “make xxx the owner” — xxx is you! This seems to be prevalent where “system” is listed in the sharing permissions. I guess system owns the files and won’t let you add comments.

Reply

djp 11 August 2011 at 09:37:49

I just want to say thanks for this tip.

I’ve always wanted to do something like this, but never that I could. It’s very useful.

Reply

Add your Comment

Take Control ebooks (affiliate link) are superb.
I do some of my best learning from them. Buy through my link so I can make more and better Tips.

Take Control of Using Lion.   Buy Take Control of iCloud.  Macworld iPhone 4S Superguide   Take Control of iTunes 10: The FAQ, Second Edition